HomeLocal NewsHow WikiLeaks set back democracy in Zim

How WikiLeaks set back democracy in Zim


Last year, early on Christmas Eve morning, representatives from the United States, United Kingdom, Netherlands, and the European Union(EU) arrived for a meeting with then Zimbabwean opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai.

Appointed Prime Minister earlier that year as part of a power-sharing agreement after the alleged fraud-and violence-ridden 2008 presidential election, Tsvangirai and his Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), are considered Zimbabwe’s greatest hopes for unseating the country’s long-time President Robert Mugabe and bringing democratic reforms to the country.

The topic of the meeting was the sanctions imposed on Zimbabwe by a collection of Western countries, including the US and EU. Tsvangirai told the Western officials that while there had been some progress in the last year, President Mugabe and his supporters were dragging their feet on delivering political reform.

To overcome this, he said that the sanctions on Zimbabwe “must be kept in place” to induce the President into giving up some political power.

The Prime Minister openly admitted the incongruity between his private support for the sanctions and his public statements in opposition.

If his political adversaries knew Tsvangirai secretly supported the sanctions, deeply unpopular with Zimbabweans, they would have a powerful weapon to attack and discredit the democratic reformer.

Later that day, the US embassy in Zimbabwe dutifully reported the details of the meeting to Washington in a confidential US State Department diplomatic cable. And slightly less than one year later, WikiLeaks released it to the world.

The reaction in Zimbabwe was swift. Zimbabwe’s President Mugabe-appointed Attorney General Johannes Tomana announced he was investigating the Prime Minister on treason charges based exclusively on the contents of the leaked cable.

While it is unlikely Tsvangirai could be convicted on the contents of the cable alone, the political damage has already been done.

The cable provides President Mugabe the opportunity to portray Tsvangirai as an agent of foreign governments working against the people of Zimbabwe.

Furthermore, it could provide President Mugabe with the pretence to abandon the coalition government that allowed Tsvangirai to become prime minister in 2009.

It is difficult to see this as anything but a major setback for democracy in Zimbabwe.

Even if Tsvangirai is not charged with treason, the opponents to democratic reforms have won a significant victory.

First, popular support for Tsvangirai and the MDC-T will suffer due to President Mugabe’s inevitable smear campaign, including Tomana’s “investigation”.

Second, the Prime Minister might be forced to take positions in opposition to the international community to avoid accusation of being a foreign corroborator.
Third, Zimbabwe’s fragile coalition government could collapse completely.

Whatever happens, democratic reforms in Zimbabwe are far less likely now than before the leak.

To their supporters, WikiLeaks and its founder Julian Assange are heroes of the democratic cause.

Assange himself has claimed that his organisation promotes democracy by strengthening the media. But in Zimbabwe, Assange’s pursuit of this noble goal has provided a supposed tyrant with the ammunition to wound, and perhaps kill, any chance for multi-party democracy.

Earlier this month, Assange claimed that “not a single person, as far as anyone is aware, has been harmed” by WikiLeaks’ practices. This is no longer true, if it ever was.

Any damage to democratic reform from WikiLeaks likely comes not from malice but naivety.
Assange is probably not best described, as US Vice-President Joe Biden recently put it, a “high-tech terrorist”.

Rather, he, his organisation, and their activist supporters believe they can promote democracy by making an enemy of secrecy itself.

What we’re seeing in Zimbabwe, however, is that those methods won’t necessarily be without significant collateral damage.

Recent Posts

Stories you will enjoy

Recommended reading