Zec in fix over Chegutu West results gaffe

THE Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (Zec) has been put in a legal fix over an alleged anomaly after it erroneously declared Zanu PF candidate for Chegutu West Dexter Nduna as the winner of last week’s polls ahead of MDC Alliance’s Gift Konjana. The error, which was committed by the district election officer identified as Maisiri, has left the commission faced with a legal challenge which could add more questions around the election’s credibility.

BY XOLISANI NCUBE

According to information availed to NewsDay, Konjana is dragging Zec to court after the commission “erred” by announcing Nduna as the MP and refused to reverse the result, saying only an electoral court could do so.

“At law, once a person is declared a winner, no one other than the court can reverse that. What is now clear is that if Konjana is very sure that he won, he could go to court and push for either re-election or him being declared winner,” a senior Zec official said .

Initially, Zec provincial officer Austin Ndlovu confirmed that Chegutu district election officer told him that there was an anomaly in the tallies announced and said that he was waiting for a comprehensive report on the issue.

Pressed further if Zec was going to reverse the final results, Ndlovu said it was too early to comment, but insisted that if it turned out that there was an anomaly, Zec would rectify the mistake.

According to a V23 form — the basis upon which the declaration was made — Nduna won the seat by 10 932 votes ahead of Konjana who garnered 10 828.

But the MDC Alliance candidate has alleged a tabulation error occurred and prejudiced him of 120 votes erroneously awarded to one Simon Kache of UCADPGPZ. Information at hand suggests that Kache got a single vote at a polling station while Konjana polled 121, but the data was mixed up. Had the mix-up not occurred, Nduna could have lost the race by four votes, but he won by a margin of 116 votes.

The Zanu PF MP and his lawyers are challenging the attempt to reverse the victory, saying the district election officer should be held liable for failing to do his work properly and such a failure should not affect their victory.

“I won this election and nothing will take that away. This attempt to reverse my victory will not be tolerated,” Nduna said.

Zec insiders said the commission was in a quandary on whether to oppose the impending legal challenge or not as some were suggesting that the commission would oppose Konjana and then later take disciplinary measures against the district election officer.


16 Comments

  1. ZEC is aligned to ZANU PF simply because it is refusing to reverse Chegutu west results when there is enough evidence which suggest that ZANU PF lost the election to MDC Alliance. Shame on you Priscilla Chigumba. God will punish you accordingly.

  2. Zec is Zanu and Zanu is Zec.

  3. This can easily be one of the cases in MDC Alliance’s legal arsenal in challenging the pfee noise-makers. We wait with bated breath.

  4. I still remember when ED was saying the voice of the people is the voice of God and people voted and the voice of people was heard now he is trying to rig God. I wish him good lucky but i don’t think he will win this. He might win in courts but he will never win it against God

  5. Educate me please. What does the Constitution say in such a scenario?

    1. I personally dont think we need the constitution at all in correcting mistakes. A mistake has to be treated as such. Under normal circumstances Zec officials ought to be charged for that offense, if not crime

  6. mmmmm not good at all. this error should be corrected without fail

  7. The Second Coming

    If ZEC opposed Konjana, taking a disciplinary action against DEO will expose their marriage with the junta. By opposing Konjana, it means ZEC will otherwise interpret that all was well with the results meaning that they will at the same time exonerating the DEO.

  8. Why don’t we wait for the court papers to be filed if at all. If there is no challenge from MDC then fair and fine.

  9. Thank you Mash west for voting wisely. zvichanaka chete mwari ndewemunhu wese.

  10. Lord save Zimbabwe

  11. Oh Lord hear us

  12. Comment…The endorsement of a person who lost the election by ZEC as a winner, reflected its incompetence.ZEC is applying selective rules.It must allow competitive ideas.ZEC must not be worse than Ian Duglas smith.The ZEC must desist from being partisan.

  13. Comment…where are the ZANU supporters now: they are all silent as death

  14. Com…where are the ZANU supporters now: they are all silent as death

  15. Kungonzwa zvese zvangotaurwa mose mototi ndizvo. Hutununu hwenyu hwakusvika kudenga chaiko. Hamukwanisi kumbobvunzawo kuti “ndizvo here ?”. Kana politics dzakutiitisa mafuza bva ngatidziregei!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.