IN public relations (PR), crises are not a matter of if but when. For practitioners, the real test of professionalism is not how loudly they celebrate success, but how calmly and diplomatically they navigate turbulence.
A crisis can threaten the very legitimacy of an organisation. Yet within every reputational storm lies an opportunity. The art of PR is the ability to turn lemons into lemonade.
Crisis situations often trigger panic. Executives demand immediate answers, stakeholders seek reassurance and the public demands accountability.
In such moments, the PR practitioner becomes strategist and stabiliser. Calmness is not optional; it is foundational. A hasty response, defensive tone or delayed communication can worsen the damage.
However, a measured, transparent and empathetic response can transform suspicion into trust.
History provides compelling examples. When Johnson & Johnson faced the Tylenol poisoning crisis in 1982, it responded not with denial but with decisive action. The company recalled millions of bottles nationwide, prioritised public safety over profits and introduced tamper-proof packaging. Instead of collapsing under the weight of scandal, the brand emerged stronger, setting global standards for crisis management. The “lemon” of product tampering became “lemonade” in the form of enhanced credibility and consumer loyalty.
Keep Reading
- Public relations: Why data analytics will save the PR profession
- Madzibaba thrills at IPRCZ awards
- Public relations: Why data analytics will save the PR profession
- Madzibaba thrills at IPRCZ awards
Similarly, when Toyota encountered massive vehicle recalls between 2009 and 2011 due to safety concerns, its initial hesitation damaged trust. However, the company eventually took responsibility, improved quality control systems and strengthened stakeholder engagement. While the crisis dented its reputation temporarily, it also prompted systemic reforms that reinforced long-term resilience.
Such examples underscore a crucial lesson: crises expose vulnerabilities. But exposure is not necessarily destruction. It is revelation. A crisis shines a spotlight on gaps in systems, communication failures, leadership weaknesses or ethical lapses. When organisations confront these gaps honestly, they not only repair reputational harm but also institutionalise learning.
How do you turn lemons into lemonade in PR?
First, transparency must guide communication. In today’s digital era, silence breeds speculation. Social media amplifies misinformation at unprecedented speed. Attempting to conceal facts often leads to greater backlash when the truth inevitably surfaces. A proactive approach of acknowledging the issue, outlining immediate steps and committing to updates is a sign of responsibility.
Second, empathy must shape messaging. Crises affect people, not just brands. Whether employees, customers, communities or investors, stakeholders need to feel heard and valued. Public apologies, when warranted, should be sincere rather than scripted. Organisations that humanise their responses often rebuild trust faster than those that rely solely on technical explanations.
Third, crises can become platforms for repositioning. Sometimes adversity offers an opportunity to clarify values and redefine identity. When handled strategically, a crisis can highlight an organisation’s commitment to reform, innovation and accountability. Stakeholders often judge organisations less on the occurrence of mistakes and more on how they respond to them.
Importantly, not every crisis will yield immediate positive outcomes. Some may result in financial losses, leadership changes or prolonged reputational repair. However, even in these cases, long-term benefits can emerge if lessons are institutionalised.
Improved governance structures, clearer communication protocols and stronger stakeholder relations can be the “lemonade” extracted from adversity.
In the African context, where organisations often operate within volatile political, economic and social environments, crisis preparedness is particularly critical. Institutions must develop crisis communication frameworks before disaster strikes. Scenario planning, media training for executives and stakeholder mapping should be routine rather than reactive. Preparedness reduces panic and enhances strategic agility.
Ultimately, turning lemons into lemonade in PR is about mindset. It requires practitioners to view crises not purely as threats but as transformative moments. It demands courage to confront uncomfortable truths and creativity to reshape narratives. Above all, it requires integrity. Without ethical grounding, no amount of spin can salvage credibility.
Thus, the proverb holds true in public relations: if life throws lemons at your organisation, do not discard them in frustration. With strategic thinking, ethical leadership and calm diplomacy, the lemons can, indeed, become lemonade — refreshing, restorative and ultimately strengthening the brand for the future.