AS organisations reach the end of the performance cycle, leaders must navigate the delicate balance between recognizing high performers and addressing difficult realities with others.
Merit season is often a period of anxiety for employees and discomfort for leaders.
Here are essential merit strategies organisations should adopt as they prepare for the hard conversations.
Equip leaders with training for tough conversations
Many uncomfortable conversations go poorly not because of the decision itself, but because leaders are unprepared to deliver it.
Organisations must invest in conversation scripts and talking points.
Keep Reading
- Out & about: Warner Music Group squashing the impossible
- Sri Lanka succumbs to China’s debt-trap diplomacy: Report
- Dynamite comes in small packages in Pastor Chirinda
- Ex-ChiTown chamber secretary fails to stop trial
For management to lead effectively, gain loyalty and respect, they have to prepare their message and frame it for various situations.
Also, they have to come up with a communication strategy on how to best relay feedback during difficult performance conversations.
The communication strategy aids management in efficiently crafting their message for a particular situation to communicate clearly and confidently.
This approach helps management in handling high-stakes discussions.
There are principles for equipping leaders to become effective communicators which a forward-thinking and progressive manager should adopt; some of them are briefly explained below:
When addressing issues, focus on issues rather than making assumptions about attitude and personality.
In crafting a message, be clear, concise and honest.
As a result, you will be able to articulate the vision, strategic plan and expectations using simple language that is understood by everyone.
Moreover, such conversations require one to be transparent to build trust.
As a forward-thinking manager, it is essential to ensure that every important conversation ends with clear and agreed-upon steps and commitments.
Techniques for handling emotional reactions
For management to handle emotional reactions, they have to engage in introspection and check their emotional strengths and flaws.
Then, come up with systems to manage their emotions by identifying triggers and mastering how their feelings influence their behaviour.
At times during tough conversations, emotions escalate; be calm before you respond and carefully select words to speak.
However, if you realise that the situation has become tense, it’s a no-brainer to temporarily step out and return when tempers have subsided.
On the other hand, as a manager, you have to create a conducive system to enable workers to express themselves without fear of negative consequences.
It is essential to create platforms which would enable human resources to express themselves.
In such a scenario, use reflective statements to show that you have understood them.
Also, acknowledge and accept employee’s emotions while devising ways to help them.
The biggest driver of discomfort in merit conversations is ambiguity.
Organisations should communicate the evaluation process well before the conversations start.
Employees naturally feel anxious and uncertain if the expectations are unclear and the rationale behind decisions is not transparent.
Leadership should use standardised performance criteria tied to measurable outcomes and explain constraints, which might include pay equity adjustments, business performance, and tight budgets, at the earliest possible time.
It is the role of the manager to keep everyone in the picture and explain during meetings how decisions were arrived at.
Some of the human capital may want to know why outcomes differ across individuals.
As such, managers play a key role in explaining why there are disparities in their outcomes.
Reinforce a culture of accountability and fairness
Merit programmes lose credibility when rewards don’t align with performance, behaviour and organisational values.
Organisations should ensure that there is consistency across functions.
To ensure fairness, managers have to lead by example and establish a system that nurtures open communication and feedback.
Lastly, the company has to develop and enforce policies that are fair and applied uniformly across the organisation.
Validate decisions through calibration sessions
The process ensures that decisions are consistent, fair and aligned with agreed standards.
This is an essential mechanism for ensuring fairness, consistency and credibility in the merit process.
A structured environment is created where assumptions can be challenged and standards can be aligned across the organisation.
Calibration helps eliminate bias, both individual and systemic, by giving leaders the opportunity to validate whether the decisions they are making truly mirror performance and organisational priorities.
Celebrate high performers visibly and fairly
Organisations should come up with a structured system to motivate human capital, including programs that involve public praise.
This approach involves recognising an achiever during a meeting or featuring the standout employee in a company magasine or website.
The company could also offer visible rewards such as a prize for being the best employee in a particular month.
The main thrust of this approach is to ensure the process is fair and aligned to the mission and vision of the organisation.
When leaders celebrate excellence visibly and fairly, they reinforce the behaviours, values and results the organisation wants to amplify.
When it’s all said and done, tough conversations during merit calibration are not simply about ratings.
They are about reinforcing the kind of culture the organisation wants to build.
When the leadership embraces clarity and challenges ambiguity, validates decisions through thoughtful calibration, and recognises high performers visibly and fairly, they transform difficult moments into meaningful opportunities.