Judge blasts govt over Mbada closure

THE government’s decision to forcibly close Grandwell Holdings (Mbada Diamonds) mining operations in Chiadzwa, has been castigated by the High Court as an act against the rule of law.

BY CHARLES LAITON

gavel-2

But in his 21-page judgment, Justice Joseph Mafusire ruled that the mining firm cannot continue operations until the validity of its special grants has been regularised in accordance with the law.

Grandwell Holdings, who are the major shareholders of Mbada Diamonds, had filed an application last month challenging the government’s decision to withdraw its licence to mine diamonds in Chiadzwa.

“It is, hereby, declared that the actions of the respondents (Mines minister Walter Chidakwa, Zimbabwe Mining Development Corporation (ZMDC), Marange Resources, Zimbabwe Consolidated Diamond Company (ZCDC) and Commissioner-General of Police (Augustine Chihuri) on February 22 amounted to an act of spoliation against the fifth respondent (Mbada Diamonds) in respect of its occupation, and operations at, the diamond mining site at the Chiadzwa Concession,” Justice Mafusire said.

In its application, Mbada Diamonds had claimed the government committed an act of spoliation and, therefore, wanted the court to intervene and issue an order restoring their position.

Justice Mafusire said if the government had discovered Mbada Diamonds’ special grants had expired, it was obliged to follow the law, as opposed to forcibly closing the mining operations.

“If the respondents suddenly discovered that the special grants had expired and wanted to terminate the marriage, they were obliged to follow the law,” the judge said.

“They were not entitled to take the law into their own hands and cause the forcible closure of the mine…At any rate, in the circumstances of this case, the respondents’ actions are difficult to understand.”

The judge said it seemed true that the special grants expired in 2010 and others in 2013, yet Mbada had continued mining. He further said sometime in September last year, ZMDC had written to the Mines ministry permanent secretary, expressly pointing out that the special grants had expired and sought a further exemption, but the government did not move in to shut the mines then.

“For action only to be taken as late as February 2016 seemed to lend credence to the complaint by Grandwell that the government was punishing the foreign investors for seemingly dragging their feet, or refusing to comply, with the consolidation scheme,” Justice Mafusire said.

“The government had all the time to act lawfully, so why the rush? Why the sudden emergency? . . . Therefore, in my finding, an act of spoliation was committed by the respondents on Mbada, however, that is not the end of the matter.”

Turning to the issue of Mbada’s application seeking to return to site, the judge said it seemed obvious that the mines’ special grants had expired and “with that Mbada’s right to possession had terminated”.

“Efforts to renew the special grants in September 2015 failed. In terms of section 291 of the Mines and Minerals Act, a special grant is the authority that gives one the title to minerals. In terms of section 2, the dominium in (occupation), and the right of searching, mining and disposing of all minerals is vested in the State President (Robert Mugabe).

“In casu (In this case), to allow Mbada to resume mining operations as before, when the right to do so expired, is to sanction an illegality.”

Justice Mafusire granted Mbada an interim relief interdicting Chidakwa, ZMDC, ZCDC, and the police from inducing, or forcing or in any manner procuring, a breach of the third respondents’ (Marange Resources) contractual relationship with the applicant (Grandwell Holdings) and the fifth respondent (Mbada Diamonds)”.

He said once the validity of the special grant has been regularised, Chidakwa, ZMDC, ZCDC, Chihuri and their agents or anyone acting on their behalf or under their instructions, “shall be interdicted from interfering with Mbada’s lawful operations at the mine.

“For all the purposes of safeguarding assets, all of the fifth respondent’s security personnel, with all their chain of command, shall be entitled, authorised and empowered to remain at the fifth respondent’s mining site at Chiadzwa Diamond Concession, as directed in paragraph two of the order of this court on 29 February 2016, until the resolution of this matter,” the judge added.

4 Responses to Judge blasts govt over Mbada closure

  1. Metellus Cimber March 17, 2016 at 9:20 am #

    Similar to the land reform. Why the rush? The Government had all the time in its favour according to the Lancaster House Agreement which expired in 1990. Why the rush and plunder that followed in the year 2000, ten years after the deadline, causing destruction and death along the way.

  2. Enzo Shumba March 17, 2016 at 10:06 am #

    The Judiciary is in shambles, they cannot stand for the truth though they know it. This is like the infamous Labour ruling, the interested parties are the ones who take decisions. These guys can not bite the hand that feeds them, we are desperate for an Independent Court in the Sadcc. At this rate we will all continue mourning with no solutions in sight.

  3. kitsi March 17, 2016 at 10:46 am #

    I think both of them are thieves. Mbada is anchored on some things they are not revealing thus suing the gvt. The gvt on the other hand realized that much has been stollen from them than what they had actually benefited.
    Remember “nobody says everything”

  4. jjajja maria March 17, 2016 at 1:38 pm #

    SHE SAVED MY MARRIAGE AND BLESSED ME FINANCIALLY THROUGH A SPECIAL PRAYERS THAT ACTIVATED THE ANOINTING OIL WHICH ALSO CONQUERED MY ENEMIES AT MY WORK PLACE.Several years of unhappiness in my marriage led to loneliness, continuous crying and suffering,after hearing about mama with a healing hand,i decided to visit her in her temple where she read my fortune accurately and told me about my past life,my marriage and business and in a MAGIC POT OF ANOINTED OIL.She performed a special prayer according to the BIBLE IN THE BOOK OF RUTH CHAPTER 1, NAOMITOLD RUTH TO WASH HERSELF AND PUT THE ANOINTING OIL ON AND GO AND LAY BESIDE BOAZ AND HE WOULD ACCEPT HER AND MARRY HER! SHE DID AND HE MARRIED HER! and in less than 3 days all my problems were over and I`m very happy in my marriage and my husband left his girl friend and came back to me.She also gave me powerful magic pot to boost my business and its stability and paid all my debts,ring to protect me from my enemies,magic wallet to increase my financial blessings and promotion at work .There is no any other way i can thank you but to tell others about you and
    your work!contact her +27735333936 email her ,healingsonly@gmail.com

© 2016 NewsDay Zimbabwe. All Rights Reserved.

DMMA logo