Safa lodges appeal with Caf

By The NewsDay | Oct. 11, 2011 | 2 Min read

JOHANNESBURG — The South African Football Association (Safa) has lodged an appeal with the Confederation of African Football (Caf) regarding the outcome of qualification for the 2012 Africa Cup of Nations tournament to be held in Equatorial Guinea and Gabon. South Africa finished top of Group G on goal difference, followed by Sierra Leone and […]

South Africa finished top of Group G on goal difference, followed by Sierra Leone and Niger — all tied on nine points, with Egypt in fourth place four points adrift. But according to Caf rules, Bafana Bafana miss out while Niger proceed to the finals next year.

South Africa played to a goalless draw against Sierra Leone at the Mbombela Stadium in Nelspruit, while Egypt defeated Niger by three goals to nil.

In a letter addressed to Caf, Saf states: “We have noted that Caf has announced that Niger have qualified in our group, despite South Africa finishing on top of the group in terms of goal difference, which is the universally recognised means of separating teams who are equal on points.

“We understand that you are using rule 14,1 to make your determination. However, we believe that the team finishing top of the log at the end of the competition is automatically determined at the end of 90 minutes play and that the second place is determined by the other rules.

“We will lay out our objection more fully shortly, but in the meantime wish to signal that we intend to challenge this interpretation and application of the rules.”

Safa has taken legal opinion on the matter and has found precedent where competition rules that are patently unfair have been overturned on appeal. Addressing the team after the match, Safa president Kirsten Nematandani had this to say:

“Do not despair, all is not lost. We believe we have a case and we will carry this fight all the way. If Caf’s rules are ambiguous then we need to challenge that and we are well within our rights to do so.