Opinion & Analysis

When a child ‘consents’ (Part 2)

NewsDay Staff ·

When a child ‘consents’ (Part 2)

PART 1 of this series examined the High Court’s decision in S v Ngwenya (HB 48/26), in which a 21-year-old man convicted of having sexual intercourse with a 14-year-old girl living in his household had his effective 21-month prison sentence set aside as excessive; in part because the High Court reasoned that he was “barely 4 years outside the protected bracket” of section 70(3) of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act [Chapter 9:23] and that this proximity ought to count in his favour.

We argued that treating an adult’s nearness to that bracket as mitigation inverts the purpose of a provision that Parliament designed to protect children from prosecution, not to grade the leniency available to the adults who exploit them. Grooming, we noted, manufactures the appearance of a child’s willing participation; that appearance is evidence of the abuse, not a defence to it.

This story is for NewsDay subscribers.